Should we add enhancements requiring JavaScript?

Welcome to Geeklog Saturday, December 15 2018 @ 10:41 pm EST

1/1: Should we add enhancements requiring JavaScript?

Yes Supporting all modern browsers		222 (56.78%)
No Must be fully functional with no JS requirement		142 (36.32%)
Don't care		27 (6.91%)

Other polls | 391 voters

Should we add enhancements requiring JavaScript? | 6 comments | Create New Account

The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.

JS yes, requirement no...
Authored by: Anonymous on Sunday, August 20 2006 @ 09:43 pm EDT

Hi,

I voted yes, but to be honest I would like to see fallback functionality so that it works both ways.

I know this is aditional work but I think its worth it. Finally it depends on wether I trust a site or not and not if I trust the CMS that site uses.

---
tokyoahead.com

JS yes, requirement no...
Authored by: eg0master on Monday, August 21 2006 @ 12:33 pm EDT

I kind of second that...
JS can be used to significantly enhance the user experience, but I think you should think twice before adding such enhancements and not use JS like crazy...

---
Geeklog Plugins: http://plugincms.com

---
Geeklog Plugins: http://plugincms.com

JS yes, requirement no...
Authored by: Blaine on Monday, August 21 2006 @ 03:42 pm EDT

If we ever want to see any AJAX features then you will need Javascript but yes, it's possible (but alot of extra work) to create site features that are basic without JS and enhanced if javascript enabled. The new yahoo.com site is an excellent example.

Still I do really wonder how many users don't leave their browsers with JS enabled and leaves me thinking it requires spending 3x the effort to add features that work both ways to address the needs of .05%

---
Geeklog components by PortalParts -- www.portalparts.com

---
Geeklog components by PortalParts -- www.portalparts.com

Concentrate on the correct thing
Authored by: eg0master on Wednesday, August 23 2006 @ 03:59 pm EDT

The idea of having basic functionality if not JS enabled and enhanced experience with JS enabled is the most applealing to me.
I agree there is no point in spending lots of time to make the same functionality with and without JS.

My point is that you should use JS (especially AJAX can be used this way) to significantly increase the experience of the user. But you shoudl not add it all over the place if it really doesn't make that big difference. In theory you could make everything work with ajax never reloading the page but there is no point in that, is there?

---
Geeklog Plugins: http://plugincms.com

---
Geeklog Plugins: http://plugincms.com

Majority of viewers.
Authored by: drshakagee on Tuesday, October 10 2006 @ 03:26 pm EDT

If the majority of your viewers have Javascript enabled then by all means use it. Users with javascript disabled are used to lots of stuff on lots of sites not working, it's their choice. As long as it's compatible with as many browsers as possible javascript is a great tool.

If you get into the fine details of what to use and what not to use because a very small amount of users don't have a specific setting enabled then you really limit your options as a web developer.

Should we never use pictures on websites because some people prefer text-only browsers? Should every website be limited to 550 pixel width because some people have 640x480 monitors? Should we never use the color red on websites because some viewers might be color blind?

---
Yes I am mental.

---
Yes I am mental.

Majority of viewers.
Authored by: Anonymous on Wednesday, December 20 2006 @ 02:44 am EST

The question of JS yes or no is not a question like images or screen width. Its not about tech advances.
Its a question about security. JS is abused on a lot of malicious sites and therefore it is better for everyone's security to switch it off despite its nice usability addons.

We basically lock out the security aware users if we make it required for everyone to use the site.

---
tokyoahead.com

---
Yes I am mental.

Warning: Javascript required to enable functionality

Geeklog

Search

Resources

About

Getting started

Support

Development

Topics

User Functions

What's New

Articles last 4 weeks

Comments last 4 weeks

Pages last 4 weeks

Links last 4 weeks

Downloads last 4 weeks